Writer: Mila Beerson
Editor: Erik Gillham
Associate Editor: Francisca Puiatti
I. Introduction
Where should the line be drawn between parents’ right to educate their child as they see fit and the state’s responsibility to ensure the child’s educational needs are met? In the United States, parents have a constitutionally recognized interest in guiding their children’s upbringing and education.1 Through United States Supreme Court cases such as Meyer v. Nebraska (1923) and Pierce v. Society of Sisters (1925), the Court recognized the importance of parental rights in educational decisions. In Meyer v. Nebraska, the Court recognized that the Fourteenth Amendment protects parents’ right to direct their children’s education.2 In Pierce v. Society of Sisters, the Court ruled that the state could not require children to attend public schools exclusively.3 Together, these cases helped establish the foundation for modern substantive due process jurisprudence.
However, these decisions do not determine the extent to which states can regulate homeschooling. Although the Supreme Court has recognized parents’ right to direct their children’s education, that does not eliminate the state’s responsibility to protect children and ensure they receive an adequate education.4 The substantial differences between state homeschooling regulations, particularly regarding academic assessments and educational oversight, raise concerns about whether existing safeguards sufficiently protect homeschooled children from educational neglect.5 Examining these differences reveals the need to consider how states can preserve parental autonomy while maintaining meaningful standards of educational accountability.
II. Variations in State Homeschooling Laws
In the United States, each state uses different educational plans, instructional standards, and academic assessments, introducing significant variance within homeschooling practices.6 Many states have adopted different approaches to balancing parental educational rights with the state’s responsibility to ensure that children are properly educated.7 However, differences in state oversight requirements and enforcement mechanisms can greatly influence a state’s ability to evaluate a homeschooled child’s academic progress.
For example, Massachusetts requires school districts to evaluate whether the homeschooling curriculum can provide adequate educational progress before allowing parents to begin a homeschooling program with their child.8 New York expands upon this by requiring parents to report an individualized home instruction plan, quarterly progress reports, and an annual assessment.9 Regularly evaluating homeschooled children to see if they meet state education standards can safeguard students from educational neglect.
In contrast, Alaska exempts children educated at home by a parent or legal guardian from its compulsory attendance requirements under Alaska Statute § 14.30.010(b)(12). Under this exemption, homeschooling generally does not require registration, advance approval, or routine academic testing.10 Consequently, Alaska’s statutory framework provides fewer formal opportunities for the state to assess students’ educational progress.
Some states, such as North and South Carolina, have adopted a more moderate approach. While these states do not provide home instruction plans or programs for specific subjects such as in states like New York, they must still administer standardized tests and ensure that the instructor at home is teacher certified.11 Measures like these could help ensure that children receive an adequate education while also protecting parents’ civil liberties.
These differences in state regulation raise questions about whether children receive consistent statutory protection against educational neglect. While parental instruction can provide a meaningful education, limited assessment and reporting can make it more difficult to identify educational deficiencies.12
III. Inadequate Oversight
One of the main concerns regarding limited oversight in homeschooling is the possibility that children may not receive the education and protection that they need. When states do not have a requirement for regular academic assessment or evidence of instruction, it can become more difficult to identify when a child is falling behind or not receiving an adequate education.13 Although homeschooling has the opportunity to provide children with a valuable and supportive learning environment, the significant differences in state regulations continue to raise concerns about whether every child has sufficient educational accountability.14
When children are withdrawn from school and have fewer opportunities for outside contact, there are fewer opportunities for someone to identify signs of abuse.15 Traditional schools provide opportunities for children to have regular contact with teachers, school nurses, counselors, and other adults who might be able to recognize signs of abuse and neglect.16 These individuals may notice possible changes in a child’s behavior, including unexplained injuries or difficulties that could suggest a child needs additional support.17 Limited contact with adults outside of the family can make potential child maltreatment more difficult to identify, although the overall relationship between homeschooling and maltreatment continues to remain limited.18 Homeschooling is not harmful in itself, but concerns should be raised on how children can be protected when regular opportunities for outside observation are substantially reduced.19
Following the tragic passing of Matthew Tirado due to prolonged abuse and neglect, the Connecticut Office of the Child Advocate examined the state’s procedures for children who were withdrawn to be homeschooled.20 Connecticut’s framework is especially permissive and is ranked as one of the least regulated states in America.21 Under Connecticut law, parents are not legally mandated to register with their local school district or fill out a “Notice of Intent” to homeschool their child.22 Furthermore, the state also does not require any periodic academic assessments, standardized testing, or portfolio reviews to verify that any instruction or lesson is occurring.23
When Matthew’s younger sister had also been withdrawn from school, further investigation found that there was no evidence that she was actually being homeschooled.24 The report found gaps in the state’s follow-up procedures, raising concerns about how a child could leave the school system without meaningful and consistent confirmation that they were continuing their education.25 Although this case does not establish that homeschooling can lead to abuse or neglect, it demonstrates that serious consequences can arise when there are gaps in homeschooling oversight.
IV. Conclusion
To protect children’s well-being and access to education while also protecting the right of families to make education decisions without unnecessary government interference, reasonable safeguards such as periodic academic assessments and follow-up appointments can reduce the prevalence of educational neglect.26 Differences in state homeschooling laws raise an important question about whether current regulations appropriately protect children’s educational welfare while still respecting parents’ constitutional rights. Ensuring that every child receives a proper education and has access to suitable protection should remain at the center of that balance.
- U.S. Const. amend. XIV, § 1. ↩︎
- Meyer v. Nebraska, 262 U.S. 390 (1923). ↩︎
- Pierce v. Soc’y of Sisters, 268 U.S. 510 (1925). ↩︎
- James G. Dwyer, Pierce’s Problems, 100 Notre Dame L. Rev. 1569 (2025). ↩︎
- Gabrielle Brown, Note, The Hidden Children of Homeschooling, 66 B.C. L. Rev. 979 (2025). ↩︎
- Elizabeth Bartholet, Homeschooling: Parent Rights Absolutism vs. Child Rights to Education & Protection, 62 Ariz. L. Rev. 1 (2020). ↩︎
- Id. ↩︎
- Care & Prot. of Charles, 504 N.E.2d 592 (Mass. 1987). ↩︎
- N.Y. Comp. Codes R. & Regs. tit. 8, § 100.10 (2026). ↩︎
- Alaska Stat. § 14.30.010(b)(12) (2024). ↩︎
- N.C. Gen. Stat. § 115C-564. ↩︎
- Bartholet, supra note 6, at 11–12. ↩︎
- Bartholet, supra note 6, at 14. ↩︎
- Megan M. Tylenda, Raising the Bar for Parental Choice: Establishing and Improving Regulations for Homeschooling, 17 Alb. Gov’t L. Rev. 1 (2023). ↩︎
- Id. ↩︎
- Brown, supra note 5, at 995–96. ↩︎
- Id. ↩︎
- Anneliese Luck et al., Homeschooling and Child Maltreatment: A Review of the Regulatory Context and Research Evidence in the United States, 163 Child Abuse & Neglect 107355 (2025). ↩︎
- Bartholet, supra note 6, at 2–3. ↩︎
- Id. ↩︎
- Calvin Clayton, Homeschooling in Connecticut: Laws & Requirements, Numa (Oct. 2026), https://numaschool.com/states/connecticut/homeschool-laws (on file with the Undergraduate Law Review at FSU). ↩︎
- See Conn. Gen. Stat. § 10-184 (2026); See also Conn. State Bd. of Educ., Guidelines for Home Instruction C-14 (1990) (defining the “Notice of Intent” as an optional form filed by parents with the local superintendent to acknowledge responsibility for providing equivalent instruction, though noting that filing remains voluntary under state law). ↩︎
- Clayton, supra note 21. ↩︎
- Id. ↩︎
- Id. ↩︎
- Tylanda, supra note 14, at 21–24. ↩︎

Leave a Reply