Reproductive Health in Florida: Prioritizing Access to Care Over Expanded Wrongful Death Liability

Writer: Isabel Reyes

Editor: Tatum Cempella

Associate Editor: Kara Crowther

I. Introduction

In 2023, Florida’s pregnancy-related mortality ratio increased to 18.5 deaths per 100,000 births, compared to 15.6 the previous year.1 However, during the 2026 legislative session just three years later, the legislature began to focus on expanding legal protections related to pregnancy.2 Senator Erin Grall’s SB 164 and its House companion, CS/HB 289, would have amended Florida’s wrongful death statute to encompass the parents of an “unborn child,” defined as a human at any stage of development in the womb, among the survivors entitled to bring a claim.3 Critics cautioned that doing so would pave the way for broader legal personhood rights, creating a slippery slope that could lead to embryos having equal rights as a living person.4 The concern is that the bill would invite more lawsuits over pregnancy outcomes, since any miscarriage, stillbirth, or pregnancy complication could be grounds for litigation.5 Research suggests that fetal personhood laws create uncertainty among physicians, leading healthcare workers to make clinical decisions out of fear of prosecution rather than patients’ best interests, resulting in reluctance to treat pregnancy complications.6

However, the bill ultimately never became law as it died in the Senate Rules Committee after passing the House floor.7 Regardless, its advancement in the 2026 legislative session undermines confidence in the state’s legislative priorities. By posing pregnancy as a question for the courts, the legislature made reproductive health a matter of liability rather than exploring measures to improve access to reproductive health services. Florida’s true reproductive health issue is not rooted in liability, but rather in a lack of access to care. Instead of passing liability bills, Florida should pivot towards expanding access to reproductive health services, redirect funding towards more OB-GYNs in marginalized areas, and expand health coverage for all women.

II. Florida Is Not Making Care Accessible

The legislature fails its pregnant residents by leaving two issues unaddressed: There are limited locations to receive care and a high number of women who lack the coverage to obtain it. March of Dimes, a nonprofit dedicated to preventing preterm birth, infant mortality, and maternal health risks, identifies thirteen counties in Florida as maternity healthcare deserts, and almost 11% of Floridians live more than thirty minutes away from a birthing hospital.8 Most affected counties are in the Panhandle, but some, such as Hardee, Glades, and Hendry, are in central Florida.9 For these people, the consequences of inaccessibility are well documented. A national study in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) found that rural counties that lost hospital-based obstetric care saw increases in out-of-hospital births and preterm births.10 Florida’s maternity care deserts are exactly the kind of place where those risks concentrate.

Coverage gaps amongst these impoverished communities exacerbate the problem. Florida remains among the few states that have not expanded Medicaid, and adults under sixty-five who are not disabled or caring for minor children remain ineligible for care despite having a low income.11 KFF estimates that about 260,000 Florida adults fall into the coverage gap.12 For women, this gap means that coverage begins after they are pregnant, which can make chronic diseases unmanageable and can also increase the risk of complications during pregnancy.13

Moreover, Erica L. Eliason, a public health researcher at Rutgers School of Public Health, found that expansion of Medicaid was associated with about seven fewer maternal deaths per 100,000 live births than in non-expansion states, particularly affecting non-Hispanic black mothers.14 In Florida, black mothers experienced a pregnancy-related death rate that was nearly three times higher than the rate for white mothers in 2018.15 By leaving Medicaid unexpanded, Florida is putting these mothers at the highest risk when they are most likely to need medical care. By focusing on access to reproductive healthcare, the legislature can improve maternal health outcomes that would otherwise be addressed through litigation.

III. Prioritizing Care Over Liability

Liability legislation is not neutral for healthcare providers. In an analysis published in JAMA, researchers investigated how state laws expanding fetal personhood affected healthcare personnel.16 Legal scholars found that fetal personhood language is already covered in civil wrongful death statutes in over forty states, and that its expansion increases civil and criminal liability for reproductive healthcare workers.17 They also warn that if prenatal care faces increased scrutiny, documentation burdens and liability may rise for clinicians providing prenatal care. Older research demonstrates that liability pressure led to the decline in obstetric supply. In 1992, a Washington State survey of family physicians and obstetricians cited excessive malpractice premiums and fear of being sued as reasons for leaving the practice.18

Litigation measures tend to rarely provide pregnant women with any concrete assistance. Researchers epitomize this by referencing laws that allow pregnant women to seek child support from conception failing to be invoked due to the lack of guidance on the required documentation.19 While lawmakers continue to pursue anti-abortion goals, necessary measures to benefit their pregnant constituents, such as Medicaid coverage for postpartum care, continue to be neglected.20

Workforce investments address that gap. In Colorado, individuals who retained Medicaid coverage were associated with a 20.5-percentage-point increase in use of mental health medication or outpatient treatment compared with commercial insurance.21 A study of New York and Texas found that 12-month coverage increased outpatient care among women with diabetes or hypertensive disorders of pregnancy.22 In 2022, Florida adopted a 12-month extension, but it does not benefit women who are uninsured before pregnancy.23 From the provider’s end, a review of specialized rural medical residency programs found that 76% of graduates practiced in rural America and 65% provided obstetrical care, but warned that programs this small could not satisfy rural needs without significant funding.24

IV. Conclusion

A legislature that claims to protect pregnant women cannot do so by redefining fetal personhood while reproductive accessibility issues go unaddressed. The neglect of healthcare prioritization in rural areas has left many Florida counties without access to a licensed obstetrician-gynecologist and victim to the disparities of reproductive health outcomes.25 The women most affected by this disparity (rural, low-income, and black Floridians) are the same women the bill claims to protect, yet nothing in it changes whether they can reach a provider. Rather than addressing accessibility, the legislature leaves marginalized communities with the same barriers to care and the same disparities in outcomes. By shifting the focus from liability disputes to funding for providers and coverage, the legislature could instead take meaningful steps towards addressing both the legal concerns and underlying access conflicts.

  1. Kate Payne, As Florida Restricted Abortion, State’s Maternal Mortality Committee Went Dark, WLRN (Apr. 2026), https://www.wlrn.org/government-politics/2026-04-03/as-florida-restricted-abortion-states-maternal-mortality-committee-went-dark [https://perma.cc/J6SU-VFKY]. ↩︎
  2. Florida Session in Chaos: Big Bills Stall as Only 15 Reach Gov. DeSantis So Far, CBS12 (Mar. 2026), [https://perma.cc/9JMQ-C64P]. ↩︎
  3. S.B. 164, 2026 Leg., Reg. Sess. (Fla. 2026). ↩︎
  4. Planned Parenthood Florida Action, Abusers’ Bill of Rights – SB 164/HB 289, (Nov. 2025), https://cbs12.com/news/florida/florida-policitics-bills-laws-legislative-session-fetal-personhood-paper-straw-bans-state-bird-battle-universal-e-verify-requirements-lower-rifle-purchase-age-in-chaos-big-bills-stall-as-only-15-reach-governor-ron-desantis-so-far [https://perma.cc/37MA-UZ7E]. ↩︎
  5. ACLU of Fla., ACLU of Florida Warns SB 164 Would Unleash Miscarriage and Abortion Lawsuits Across Florida, (Jan. 2026), https://www.aclufl.org/press-releases/aclu-of-florida-warns-sb-164-would-unleash-miscarriage-and-abortion-lawsuits-across-florida/ [https://perma.cc/X6XL-D6YM]. ↩︎
  6. Taylor Riley et al., County-Level Pregnancy Criminalization Rates and Prenatal Care Initiation and Utilization in Alabama, 2014–2022, 36 Women’s Health Issues 197 (2026). ↩︎
  7. CS/HB 289: Civil Liability for the Wrongful Death of an Unborn Child, Fla. S. (Oct. 2026), https://www.flsenate.gov/Session/Bill/2026/289 [https://perma.cc/QY2H-8BKS]. ↩︎
  8. March of Dimes, March of Dimes Report Reveals Persistent Gaps in Maternity Care Access (Aug. 2026), https://www.marchofdimes.org/about/news/march-dimes-report-reveals-persistent-gaps-maternity-care-access [https://perma.cc/HB2C-B36E]. ↩︎
  9. Id. ↩︎
  10. Katy B. Kozhimannil et al., Association Between Loss of Hospital-Based Obstetric Services and Birth Outcomes in Rural Counties in the United States, 319 JAMA 1239 (2018). ↩︎
  11. Medicaid Eligibility and Enrollment in Florida, Healthinsurance.org, https://www.healthinsurance.org/medicaid/florida/ [https://perma.cc/6FJR-AGNV]. ↩︎
  12. Sammy Cervantes et al., How Many Uninsured Are in the Coverage Gap and How Many Could Be Eligible if All States Adopted the Medicaid Expansion?, KFF (July 2026), https://www.kff.org/medicaid/how-many-uninsured-are-in-the-coverage-gap-and-how-many-could-be-eligible-if-all-states-adopted-the-medicaid-expansion/ [https://perma.cc/5A3D-L6ZX]. ↩︎
  13. Alison Yager, Maternal Health in Florida: Poor Outcomes Made Worse by Lack of Medicaid Expansion (2020). ↩︎
  14. Erica L. Eliason, Adoption of Medicaid Expansion Is Associated with Lower Maternal Mortality, 30 Women’s Health Issues 147 (2020). ↩︎
  15. Id. ↩︎
  16. Carmel Shachar et al., Fetal Personhood Laws and Their Implications for Health Care, 332 JAMA 1231–32 (2024). ↩︎
  17. Id. ↩︎
  18. Thomas Greer et al., Can Physicians Be Induced to Resume Obstetric Practice?, 5 J. Am. Bd. Fam. Prac. 407 (1992). ↩︎
  19. Taelor Thornton, The Unborn Child Support Act: Support for Expecting Mothers or Pro-Fetus Personhood Act, 43 Child. Legal Rts. J. 82 (2023). ↩︎
  20. Carmel Shachar et al., Fetal Personhood Laws and Their Implications for Health Care, 332 JAMA 1231–32 (2024). ↩︎
  21. Sarah H. Gordon et al., Extended Postpartum Medicaid in Colorado Associated with Increased Treatment for Perinatal Mood and Anxiety Disorders, 43 Health Affs. 523 (2024). ↩︎
  22. Postpartum Medicaid Extensions Improve Follow-up Care for Women with Pregnancy Complications, Columbia Univ. Mailman Sch. of Pub. Health (Oct. 2026), https://www.publichealth.columbia.edu/news/postpartum-medicaid-extensions-improve-follow-care-women-pregnancy-complications [https://perma.cc/H5Z6-P6X2]. ↩︎
  23. March of Dimes, Florida Medicaid Extension (Oct. 2026), https://www.marchofdimes.org/florida-medicaid [https://perma.cc/EGK8-J2PQ]. ↩︎
  24. Thomas C. Rosenthal, Outcomes of Rural Training Tracks: A Review, 16 J. Rural Health 213 (2000). ↩︎
  25. Dominick J. Lemas et al., Perinatal Health Outcomes Across Rural and Nonrural Counties Within a Single Health System Catchment, 4 Women’s Health Reps. 169 (2023). ↩︎

Comments

One response to “Reproductive Health in Florida: Prioritizing Access to Care Over Expanded Wrongful Death Liability”

  1. Andres Santana Avatar
    Andres Santana

    Incredibly Insightful!

    Like

Leave a Reply